Nonstop flights from New York to Key West
2 airlines fly from 2 New York airports (EWR and LGA) to Key West (EYW), with up to 2 flights a day.
Routes
2 airport pairsWhen they leave
New York time10:00a10:13aFirst departure 10:00 AM, last 10:13 AM
Two in the morning, 10:00 AM to 10:13 AM. Every flight runs daily.
Every flight
Earliest first
Schedules last checked Sep 22, 2026. Times are local.
Flying from New York to Key West
American Airlines flies daily on the Embraer 175. United Airlines flies daily on the Embraer 175.
There are 2 flights every day of the week. The first arrival in Key West is at 1:29 PM and the last at 1:55 PM.
EWR to EYW is the busiest airport pair, with 7 flights a week, then LGA to EYW with 7.
On LGA to EYW, American Airlines starts on Nov 1.
Flying back, Key West to New York has 14 nonstop flights a week.
Return flights
Find the cheapest day to fly from New York to Key West.
Schedules as of Oct 9, 2026.